Can Hate Sex Ever Be Good? A Psychologist Weighs In

We hate to love it. There's no better feeling than when Lizzie and Darcy finally admit their feelings for each other—but is their storyline all that realistic?

---

It's everyone's favorite trope: two people who despise each other suddenly forgo their inhibitions and lose themselves in a steamy, intense embrace.

From Pride and Prejudice to Sex and the City's Carrie and Big, from 10 Things I Hate About You to Anyone But You—this passionate dynamic has viewers squealing for more.

But what exactly is it about hate sex that captivates us so deeply?

And more importantly: Can this dynamic be as fulfilling in real-life relationships as it appears in fiction?

At Good Kitty, we believe in exploring relationship dynamics with both candor and compassion. This article examines the psychological appeal of hate sex and offers healthier alternatives for maintaining intimate connections during conflicts.

Spoiler alert: The fantasy is way better than the reality.

---

What Makes Hate Sex So Appealing?

Esther Perel, psychotherapist and world-renowned relationship expert, explains that our erotic desire is fundamentally fueled by mystery and distance.

"Desire needs space. It is the emotional distance that you can bridge, the freedom to move from closeness to separateness."

This insight provides a compelling framework for understanding the hate sex phenomenon.

Think about it: Two people who can't stand being in the same room suddenly getting physically intimate creates massive narrative satisfaction. The tension relief when they finally connect feels cathartic.

The appeal lies in several psychological mechanisms:

🔥 1. Vulnerability Breakthrough

If someone consistently refuses emotional vulnerability, seeing them in a sexually vulnerable situation feels like a breakthrough.

Characters like Adam in Sex Education or Patrick in 10 Things I Hate About You demonstrate this when they finally let down their emotional walls through physical intimacy.

🔥 2. Tension Release

The build-up of antagonism creates a form of tension that seeks release.

Research on sexual tension shows that unresolved friction can increase arousal when it finally finds expression.

🔥 3. Power Dynamics

The shifting power dynamics when enemies become lovers creates narrative satisfaction.

This transformation represents a fundamental change in the relationship's ecosystem—and we find that compelling.

🔥 4. Forbidden Attraction

The taboo nature of being attracted to someone you "shouldn't" like can intensify desire.

This is the psychology of forbidden fruit: The more something is off-limits, the more appealing it becomes.

---

The Media Portrayal of Hostile Romance (And Why It's Problematic)

To gain professional insight, we consulted sex therapist Aleks Trkuljia from The Pleasure Centre.

She identifies this as a "problematic dynamic" that's frequently reinforced in popular media.

"There are so many different relationship dynamics in media that present this idea of 'I'm mean and guarded' which builds tension. But when you really examine it, the character is just being defensive and finally letting their guard down during sexual intimacy."

This portrayal can inadvertently normalize unhealthy relationship patterns, making audiences believe that:

❌ Hostility is a sign of underlying attraction
❌ Persistent pursuit despite rejection is romantic
❌ Physical intimacy can substitute for emotional communication
❌ Conflict doesn't require verbal resolution

These narratives, while entertaining, can shape problematic expectations about real-world relationships.

---

Popular Culture Examples of "Hate-to-Love" Dynamics

Media is filled with examples of this dynamic. Here are a few that illustrate the problems:

📺 Eric and Adam in "Sex Education"

"In the first season, Adam is bullying Eric, then when they have detention together, he kisses him," notes Trkuljia.

The problem: This portrayal suggests that bullying behavior can mask attraction and that abusive dynamics can transform into romantic ones.

🎬 Kat and Patrick in "10 Things I Hate About You"

"Patrick has an agenda in needing to take Kat out because he is getting paid," Trkuljia explains.

The problem: Despite the deception at the core of their relationship, audiences root for this couple because the hostility evolves into attraction.

💕 Carrie and Big in "Sex and the City"

Big consistently treats Carrie with emotional unavailability and dismissiveness, yet their explosive reunions are portrayed as passionate and desirable.

The problem: The narrative suggests that emotional unavailability is sexy and that pursuing someone who repeatedly hurts you is romantic.

🎥 Sydney Sweeney and Glen Powell in "Anyone But You"

The new rom-com features two people who despise each other being forced to pretend they're together—only to develop real feelings.

The problem: While less toxic than other examples, it still reinforces the idea that hostility can seamlessly transform into love.

---

The Dangerous Narrative These Stories Create

Trkuljia explains the real harm in these portrayals:

"There is this idea that the person who is often being pursued and is not consenting to the behavior now thinks it's been worthwhile to endure the abuse because they've been kissed and are being romanticized and desired and therefore are worthy."

Translation: These stories teach people (especially women) that:

• Being pursued despite saying "no" is flattering
• Enduring bad behavior is worth it if it leads to romance
• Your worth is validated by someone else's desire
• Abuse can be redeemed by attraction

This is incredibly dangerous messaging.

---

Why Hate Sex Doesn't Resolve Relationship Conflicts

While fictional portrayals make hate sex seem like an effective conflict resolution technique, the reality is quite different.

Trkuljia cautions against using physical intimacy as a substitute for emotional communication:

"If you're in a relationship and experiencing a conflict, instinct might suggest a good round in the sack, but this can be quite a problematic solution to your problems."

🚨 The Fundamental Issue: Avoiding True Communication

"The function of sex here as a resolution or conflict management or diffusion technique can be quite problematic because if the same issue continues to arise, then a cycle forms where sex is just how you diffuse the intensity and conflict. Obviously, that would mean that your emotional needs are not being met or resolved and nothing is actually changing."

In other words: You're using sex as a band-aid for deeper wounds that require actual healing.

---

The Cycle of Unresolved Emotions

🧠 The Temporary Hormonal Effect

Post-sexual intimacy, our bodies release a cascade of hormones:

🧪 Oxytocin – Creates feelings of bonding and connection
🧪 Dopamine – Generates pleasure and satisfaction
🧪 Endorphins – Produces feelings of euphoria and reduces pain
🧪 Estrogen and Testosterone – Regulates sexual desire
🧪 Cortisol – The stress hormone (can leave us on edge if stress remains unresolved)

"You do have things like endorphins and dopamine which are the bonding connection hormones, which usually spike after sex," Trkuljia explains.

However, these biochemical effects are short-lived:

"Is it possible to physically release your hate for someone? I don't think it's that simple. We feel that connection and bond and maybe feel better, but that's a very temporary solution to perhaps a long-term problem."

Think of it like this: You're taking a painkiller for a broken bone. The pain goes away temporarily, but the bone is still broken.

---

Sex as a Coping Mechanism (Not a Solution)

When sex becomes a primary method for managing relationship conflicts, it functions as a coping mechanism rather than a solution.

"Sex is often used as a coping strategy, much like drugs, alcohol, or spending money. It falls into that category of behavior that we use to mediate our emotional state," Trkuljia notes.

This comparison highlights an important distinction:

✔️ Healthy coping mechanisms address underlying issues
❌ Unhealthy coping mechanisms merely mask symptoms temporarily

🔄 The Pattern That Develops:

1. Conflict arises
2. Instead of talking it through, you have sex
3. Hormones make you feel temporarily better
4. The underlying issue remains unresolved
5. The same conflict arises again
6. Repeat cycle

Over time, this creates:

• Resentment (the same issues keep coming up)
• Communication breakdown (you've never learned to actually talk through conflicts)
• Emotional distance (physical intimacy without emotional intimacy)
• Sexual dysfunction (sex becomes associated with conflict rather than pleasure)

---

Healthier Approaches to Conflict Resolution

Trkuljia stresses that while makeup sex after resolving a conflict can be healthy and reaffirming, using sex to avoid addressing issues creates problematic patterns.

"When people are having hate sex to resolve conflict, it ends up becoming a way to become vulnerable and intimate with each other because they don't actually have the verbal or communication skills to do so. Like any unhealthy coping mechanism that we develop, we learn to do it because it's what worked at the time."

✔️ At Good Kitty, We Advocate for These Healthier Approaches:

1. Practice Active Listening

• Focus on understanding your partner's perspective before responding
• Reflect back what you've heard ("What I'm hearing is...")
• Ask clarifying questions

2. Use "I" Statements

• Express your feelings without blame
• "I feel hurt when..." rather than "You always..."
• Takes defensiveness out of the equation

3. Take Cooling-Off Periods

• Allow space for emotions to settle before addressing sensitive topics
• Agree on a timeframe to return to the conversation
• Don't use this as avoidance—actually come back to the issue

4. Seek to Understand Underlying Needs

• Look beyond the immediate conflict to deeper emotional requirements
• Ask yourself: "What do I really need right now?"
• Recognize that the surface issue might not be the real issue

5. Develop Emotional Vocabulary

• Expand your ability to identify and express specific emotions
• Move beyond "fine," "good," or "bad"
• Practice naming what you're actually feeling

6. Consider Professional Guidance

• Relationship counseling provides valuable tools for communication
• A therapist can help identify patterns you can't see on your own
• It's not a sign of failure—it's a sign of commitment

---

When Makeup Sex IS Healthy

Here's the key distinction:

❌ Hate sex/conflict sex = Using physical intimacy to avoid addressing emotional issues

✔️ Makeup sex = Using physical intimacy to reconnect after emotional issues have been addressed

Trkuljia explains: "It's completely healthy to have an argument, resolve it, and then have sex to reconnect."

The sequence matters:

1. Conflict arises
2. You communicate about it (with active listening, "I" statements, understanding needs)
3. You reach resolution or understanding
4. You have sex to reaffirm your connection

In this scenario, physical intimacy serves as a way to reaffirm connection rather than avoid communication.

---

How to Tell If You're Using Sex to Avoid Conflict Resolution

🚨 Signs You Might Be in an Unhealthy Pattern:

❌ Recurring arguments about the same issues
❌ Feeling temporarily better after sex but with underlying resentment remaining
❌ Noticing a pattern where difficult conversations are consistently diverted toward physical intimacy
❌ Conflicts remain unresolved despite regular sexual activity
❌ You have great physical chemistry but terrible emotional communication
❌ You feel closer during sex but disconnected afterwards
❌ You're avoiding the "we need to talk" conversation by initiating sex

If any of these resonate, it's time to change the pattern.

---

FAQ

Is hate sex ever healthy in a relationship?

Short answer: No.

While intense passion can sometimes emerge from conflict, true "hate" is never a healthy foundation for intimacy.

Occasional passionate encounters after minor disagreements can be normal, but consistently using sex to avoid addressing underlying issues creates harmful patterns.

Healthy relationships require both emotional and physical intimacy—not one as a substitute for the other.

Why do I find the hate-to-love trope so appealing in fiction?

The appeal often lies in:

• The dramatic transformation
• The breaking of emotional barriers
• Seeing guarded characters become vulnerable
• The tension and release pattern (activates reward centers in our brains)

However, it's important to distinguish between entertaining fiction and healthy relationship models.

Just because something makes for good TV doesn't mean it makes for a good life.

Can makeup sex be healthy after a conflict?

Yes—when it follows (rather than replaces) healthy conflict resolution.

Trkuljia explains: "It's completely healthy to have an argument, resolve it, and then have sex to reconnect."

The key distinction: The emotional issues have been addressed first, and physical intimacy serves as a way to reaffirm connection.

How can I tell if I'm using sex to avoid conflict resolution?

Ask yourself:

• Do we keep arguing about the same things?
• Do I feel better temporarily after sex but resentful later?
• Do difficult conversations consistently get diverted toward physical intimacy?
• Are our conflicts actually getting resolved?
• Do we have better physical chemistry than emotional communication?

If you answered yes to most of these, you're likely using sex as avoidance.

What steps can I take to improve conflict resolution in my relationship?

1. Evaluate your communication patterns honestly
2. Schedule time for important conversations when you're both calm
3. Practice active listening and "I" statements
4. Seek to understand underlying needs, not just surface issues
5. Consider couples counseling if patterns persist

Professional help isn't a sign of failure—it's a sign of commitment to growth.

---

The Bottom Line

Hate sex makes for great fiction but terrible relationship dynamics.

The fantasy is compelling because:

• We love seeing emotional barriers break down
• Tension and release feel satisfying
• Power dynamics create narrative interest
• Forbidden attraction is exciting

But the reality is that:

❌ Using sex to avoid communication creates harmful patterns
❌ Hormonal effects are temporary—underlying issues remain
❌ Sex becomes a coping mechanism rather than an expression of intimacy
❌ Resentment builds when real issues go unaddressed
❌ You end up with great physical chemistry but terrible emotional connection

The healthier alternative:

✔️ Address conflicts through honest, vulnerable communication
✔️ Develop emotional vocabulary and conflict resolution skills
✔️ Use makeup sex to reconnect after resolution—not to avoid resolution
✔️ Build both physical AND emotional intimacy
✔️ Seek professional help when needed

At Good Kitty, we believe that physical intimacy should enhance emotional connection, not replace it.

Your relationship deserves both passion and communication. You can have the intensity without the toxicity.

Save the hate sex for fiction. In real life, choose love, communication, and genuine connection.

---

— Meghan Carozza
Co-Founder & Chief Experience Officer, Good Kitty Co.

---

References:

• Perel, E. (2023). Erotic Intelligence: Reconciling Sensuality and Domesticity.
• Gottman, J., & Silver, N. (2021). The Seven Principles for Making Marriage Work.
• Johnson, S. M. (2022). Attachment theory in practice: Emotionally focused therapy (EFT).
• Diamond, L. M. (2023). "Sexual desire across the lifespan." American Psychologist.

Want to explore power dynamics in healthy, consensual ways? Check out The Joyful Couple card games—designed to help couples communicate about desires, boundaries, and fantasies without the dysfunction.